Skip to main content

The Leaky VLANs myth?

I have often encountered the myth that VLANs are insecure and should not be used. People who state this proceed to buy a separate switch for each LAN that they deploy. Great commission for the salesman, but bad for the business paying the premium for the extra tin!
A closer questioning of this reasoning exposes the myth that these people believe VLANs leak. My perception is that the root of this myth is a poor analysis done yonks ago and published on SANS, Intrusion Detection FAQ: Are there Vulnerabilities in VLAN Implementations? VLAN Security Test Report. This dated reports states as a recommendation: "Try not to use VLANs as a mechanism for enforcing security policy. They are great for segmenting networks, reducing broadcasts and collisions and so forth, but not as a security tool." This report is used as the basis of many flawed recommendations, see this thread. VLANs are a security tool but they are not an exclusive security tool!
VLANs are not an alternative to a firewall. Duh! VLANs are not an alternative to a router either. Duh! Firewalls (or routers) are not an alternative to VLANs. Duh! But not using VLANs, period, is short sighted and flawed. Not using VLANs is a larger risk than actually using them! Without using VLANS, it is not possible to implement a reasonably secure network design. Security is in the design and configuration, not the components! VLANs don't leak and I challenge any security bunnies out there, to provide documented proof of a successful exploit!


Popular posts from this blog

LDWin: Link Discovery for Windows

LDWin supports the following methods of link discovery: CDP - Cisco Discovery Protocol LLDP - Link Layer Discovery Protocol Download LDWin from here.

easywall - Web interface for easy use of the IPTables firewall on Linux systems written in Python3.

Firewalls are becoming increasingly important in today’s world. Hackers and automated scripts are constantly trying to invade your system and use it for Bitcoin mining, botnets or other things. To prevent these attacks, you can use a firewall on your system. IPTables is the strongest firewall in Linux because it can filter packets in the kernel before they reach the application. Using IPTables is not very easy for Linux beginners. We have created easywall - the simple IPTables web interface . The focus of the software is on easy installation and use. Access this neat software over on github: easywall

STG (SNMP Traffic Grapher)

This freeware utility allows monitoring of supporting SNMPv1 and SNMPv2c devices including Cisco. Intended as fast aid for network administrators who need prompt access to current information about state of network equipment. Access STG here (original site) or alternatively here .